6 comments on “LESEAN MCCOY or DEMARCO MURRAY

  1. It’s funny you’re defending Shady here considering how you used to rip him and his play. If you look at their careers so far Shady’s been the better back, but these last two season with Chip Kelly have been terrible for his body. Nearly 700 touches in two seasons with Chip. Not that I think Shady’s slowing down. In the contrary he got better as the season went on. Shady is a guy in one season rushed for 17 touchdowns, but for some reason Chip didn’t get him the ball in the red zone. Then again his spread offense has been pretty useless in the red zone too so…. Demarco Murray is a one cut back like you wrote, but he hasn’t been close to Shady’s production until last season and he’s only played a full season once. Can Murray be the guy that bucks the trend of guys with over 400 carries in one season falling off the map? I don’t yet, just like I don’t know how many of Chip’s changes are going to produce. Funny thing is McCoy has had more carries/touches than Murray, but he’s actually the younger back. Truthfully at this point if I had to chose one of them I would say neither. Realistically both have two to three more productive seasons left, and cost too much money. Chip’s offense calls for a guy to just run it between the tackles and not necessarily be dynamic. A rookie could have done that and far cheaper than any of the tree backs the Eagles have on the roster right now. Chip should have drafted McCoy’s replacement last season. Smart franchises groom replacements. They don’t abruptly end relationships with quality players and not have some kind of plan to replace that player. Chip has a lot of bad ingredients working right now. Too many new players. Too many players returning from injuries, and a lack of young players being groomed to replace some of these aging veterans. Most importantly in this league you need a legit QB to win. Is Sam Bradford that guy? Well so far (unless you’re willing to give him a bunch of excuses) Sam Bradford hasn’t shown he is nor has he shown he can be. I don’t like his chances to prove otherwise considering this offense has had 4 starting QB injuries in two seasons.

    Liked by 1 person

    • I’m less defending McCoy and more pointing out that he’s the more special player between the two. As I said, if I had those TWO to pick from. (Starting from scratch, I’d go with a RB like Arian Foster or LeVeon Bell.)

      Like

      • Foster is a prime example that you don’t need to invest early picks on backs and he’s also an example of a back who gets a ton of touches eventually breaking down. If Chip wants to run sets with multiple backs I don’t get why he decided to sign and trade for old ones and on top of that he decided to go with very young receivers. Seems to me in the NFL it is much harder to learn how to be a receiver than it is to learn how to be a running back. I’m just not that sold on GM Chip.

        Liked by 1 person

COMMENTS

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s